View Full Version: Reviews on MYBBT

newradicals >>New Radicals Forum >>Reviews on MYBBT


Marisa- 09-12-2006
Reviews on MYBBT
Reviews of releases from the New Radicals and Robert Earl Keen Contents Daily News, New York Daily News, New York ~~~~~~~~ By Jim Farber Every season has its overlooked gems. Here's a selection of deserving recent discs we missed: NEW RADICALS ``Maybe You've Been Brainwashed Too'' (MCA) The New Radicals are neither. They're as old as the hills when it comes to crafting glistening pop melodies and bracingly clear lyrics. In fact, they allude to so many sounds of the '60s and '70s, they can sometimes seem as much a collection of references as a band. Luckily, they're never quite consumed by their allusions. Instead they come off most like Karl Wallinger's band World Party, which found consistently clever ways to give '60s rock its own melodies and lyrical point of view. Radical leader Gregg Alexandereven sounds a bit like Wallinger when he sings - not to mention like Jagger, but with finer chops and less swagger. That is, when he's not sounding like Paul Weller doing a take on the falsettos of Curtis Mayfield and Marvin Gaye. In ``I Hope I Didn't Just Give Away the Ending,'' Alexander even puts a new spin on the background babble of Gaye classics like ``Mercy Mercy Me,'' by erecting his own layers of patter. In his bottomless grab bag of influences, you'll hear lilts of The Who's piano parts from ``Quadrophenia'' and the stutter of a Zeppelin riff, made more fleet - both employed within meters of each other during ``In Need of a Miracle.'' Alexander takes his main cues from the perfection of Beatles verses and the exuberance of Motown choruses. You'll hear both in the single ``You Get What You Give,'' currently a minor hit on Modern Rock Radio. Since nearly every song on the New Radicals' album offers just as catchy a tune, don't be surprised if this becomes the first breakout LP of '99. Certainly it deserves to be. Not only are the melodies and arrangements fetching, Alexander's lyrics sketch a fresh and likeable character: an optimist surrounded by cynics. Alexander's character constantly chases flaky, smart girls - overeducated druggies, essentially - the types who would find his jubilant view uncool if it weren't spiked by a contrary pluck. In that way, Alexander makes his positive attitude smart - as opposed to most pop, which naively yearns to believe good things can be true. It's yet one more element that helps Alexander reinvent antique pop, another way to make everything old sound new again. Maybe that's a radical act, after all. (c) 1999, New York Daily News. Visit the Daily News online at http://www.nydailynews.com/ Distributed by Knight Ridder/Tribune Information Services. Maybe You've Been Brainwashed Too 1 ( 1998 ) Mother We Just Can't Get Enough / You Get What You Give / I Hope I Didn't Just Give Away the Ending / I Don't Wanna Die Anymore / Jehovah Made This Whole Joint for You / Someday We'll Know / Maybe You've Been Brainwashed Too / In Need of a Miracle / Gotta Stay High / Technicolor Lover / Flowers / Crying Like a Church on Monday One hit wonders are more commonly associated with either Rap artists or novelty pop, no disparagement to Rap intended - and no, I'm not about to mention Vanilla Ice either! But, first of all we have a little mock Rock N Roll guitar part leading into the Eighties pop of 'Mother We Just Can't Get Enough'. Eighties Pop? Yes, well. Stranger things have happened. It actually starts out a pretty nice song but it's far too long at over five minutes to justify it's existence. What do I mean by that? Well, it sounds nice, pretty good in fact, but only for about two minutes. That's all the time you actually need to hear everything the song has to offer. The other three minutes only provide more Bono from U2 style vocal wailing in the worst possible 'tribute' to Bono you could imagine, mix in a little semi-rap 'funk' section of vocals, and there you go. A perfectly good song triumphantly ruined and slammed into the realms of complete unsubtly and extreme annoyance factor. Speaking of which, 'You Get What You Give' is one of those songs. The first thirty seconds of hearing it played for the umpteenth time on the radio sounds great! Hey, perfect pop to go! It is in fact one of the most obvious and irritating songs ever written, and the very fact The New Radicals were unable to follow it up ( they split up in fact! ) seems to prove this is one of those songs, that for inexplicable reasons captures the imagination of the general public above and beyond that which the song actually deserves. I mean, it offers nothing new. Thirty-something's may well have nodded their heads in appreciation at this reprise of one of the worst years for charting rock and pop (1988, in case you were wondering) but the rest of us wanted to puke after around a minute of listening to the song. The rest? I think I've brought this up in other reviews of other artists. I want a song TO PROGRESS! Especially if it's a pop song! The likes of the Velvet Underground may very well be able to stretch a single groove over eighteen minutes, but then, they offer stupid lyrics that change throughout the song, no chorus, distortion - the blissful variety of random distortion! What happened to pop songs having interesting middle eights? Cos this bloody doesn't! 'You Get What You Give' is a poor song, but a good late Eighties pop single. Shame it was released in the late Nineties, really. Even more of a shame it became a massive hit, but what are you gonna do? Even more a shame is the fact the rest of this album is even more hideously worse than even the mediocre two songs which open this set. 'I Hope I Didn't Give Away' is full of mock soul and totally unconvincing and shambolic although actually presented as a shiny pop song. Which, doesn't make sense to me. It's lacking in execution, let's put it that way and the vocals are very wayward, to say the least. 'I Don't Wanna Die Anymore' is vomit inducing with a whining sounding vocal to the nth degree. If you're gonna whine about how miserable you are, at least offer a little desolate romance for the lost romantic poets to latch onto! 'I Don't Wanna Die Anymore'? Why? This sorry excuse for a ballad has cheered you up, has it? Have you met a wonderful girl? Are you filled with rage? Have you suddenly taken singing lessons? Ah, forget it. To be honest, I can't even be bothered to do a song by song analysis of this sorry excuse of an album. We get more bland, more lacking in imagination, more lack of anything even slightly new. We get lots more wayward vocals. Now, wayward is ok, if the voice has character. But, these vocals don't have character. Sure, they sound distinctive. That alone doesn't equal character. This is just a singer, who can't sing. He tried his best, I'll give him that. He's obviously a big fan of soul music, so that's a plus - although not when applied to this record of course, because all of his performances lack conviction and sound contrived. The execrable five minute long title track sums up everything that's bad about this entire album. A hole in the middle of nowhere has more substance than this. It's not even happy sounding! If I'm gonna get a song lacking substance, I at least want it to sound either stupidly dumb, or stupidly happy. This, is just trying. It tried my patience, anyway. But, taste is taste. I was going to say something else just now about the almost pleasant pop of 'Flowers' but it's temporarily eluded my mind. This album has that effect on people. It makes you forget you've ever even existed. 'I Don't Want To Die Anymore'? I died half way through listening to this album. http://www.adriandenning.co.uk/newradicals.html

Titan- 09-13-2006

Does anyone know where that guy is buried so I can send flowers... soaked in piss. 8mad

ULTIMAN- 09-13-2006

yeah that second one has got to be one of the worst NR reviews ive read.

Fritz- 09-13-2006

well, it's just some random unimportant review by some gut with a website. Real (e.g. payed, published) critics generally reviewed the album quite good.

ULTIMAN- 09-14-2006

thats a fairly recent board, the site was updated yesterday and that boards last activity was may 14th. lo and behold, our own irco had posted there in response along with a bunch of other NR fans. but yeah, i know what you mean, any fat kid with a webpage can write garbage.

CrypticMouse- 09-06-2007

Maybe You've Been Brainwashed Too review from Uncut magazine. May 1999. They gave it 5 stars :D Basic Instinct Classic US pop from LA-based band led by opinionated but inspired loud-mouth. There have been several contenders for the last great American rock 'n' roll album of the 20th century, Mercury Rev's Deserter's Songs and Wilco's Summer Teeth among them. Maybe You've Been Brainwashed Too could just be the last great American pop album before the millennium curtain brings it all crashing down. Gregg Alexander's New Radicals are not particularly new and the music isn't very radical , unless we have been reduced to such a sad state that the old-fashioned pop virtues of dizzily addictive hooks and infectious tunes that make their point inside three minutes have now become cutting edge. Yet what is undeniable is that the 29-year-old from Grosse Pointe, Michigan has a pop vision that begins from the premise that no way is it only rock 'n' roll. Alexander knows, to paraphrase the sainted Bill Shankly, that it is not a matter of life and death because music is far more important than that. It's all there in the ridiculously catchy "You Get What You Give" with its celebratory refain: "If you feel your dream is dying/Hold tight/You've got the music in you...you've got a reason to live." Read his interviews and Alexander can sound a bit of a berk. Music is about "making closed minds, sexism, corporate greed, economic and educational seperation of the races, homophobia and fat people phobia a thing of the past". it sounds like a Chumbawamba manifesto. Fortunately, it gets better. "I hope we don't forget the reason everybody embraces rock 'n' roll in the first place," he says. "Where else can you fuck your brains out and simultaneously fight oppression of the human spirit?" Yessss! And if that sounds naive, Alexander is actually worldly-wise. He knows "rock culture has been co-opted by soda pop companies and Wall Street" - which makes all the more delicious the irony that he is delivering his gospel courtesy of the Seagram-owned biggest record company in the world. If we can't bite the hand that feeds, we might as well all give up. Brian Wilson made Maybe... one of his five records of last year, alongside Joni Mitchell, Costello/Bacharach and Paul Simon. It's easy to see why. Of course, there are echoes of The Beach Boys but think Rundgren, Big Star, Hall & Oates, Steely Dan. Crafted pop. White soul vocals. Lots of drug references. The Old Traditionalists meet the New Radicals and, lo and behold, pop is irresistibly reinvented anew once more. The aforementioned "You Get What You Give" has already achieved notoriety for dissing label mates Beck, Courtney Love and Marilyn Manson. "You're all fakes/Run to your mansions/Come around/We'll kick your ass in," Alexander sneers with commendable relish. Then at the close of the title track he sings: "So cynical, so hip, so full of shit/They told us to shut the fuck up and write another hit." So he went away and wrote a whole LP of them, including "Jehovah Made This Whole Joint For You". Inspired. Nigel Williamson http://i28.photobucket.com/albums/c227/crypticmouse/Magazine%20Articles/UncutReview.jpg

Pablo- 09-08-2007

There are many interesting reviews on Amazon USA. Look <A HREF="http://www.amazon.com/Maybe-Youve-Been-Brainwashed-Too/dp/B00000DF6J/ref=pd_bbs_sr_1/103-5685476-5475064?ie=UTF8&s=music&qid=1189301928&sr=8-1">here</a>

Pablo- 09-08-2007

These reviews are very interesting... ;) 1 out of 5: Worst Album Ever Made!!!!!!!!!!, October 25, 2001 By Lauren (San Jose, CA) Gregg Alexander of New Radicals is not even close to talented, his lyrics are even worse. The only two good songs on this album are "Mother we just can't get enough" and "You get what you give". His lyrics should be labled explicit and not okay for kids younger then 13. I'm 13 and was not moved by this untalented loser who could not write good lyrics or music for that matter. After the second song I could not believe what I was hearing from the lyrics. While the lyrics in the first two songs were harmless to your ears, the rest of the lyrics talked about drugs,sexy girls and a bunch of other stuff that was not okay for kids under 13 to listen to.After the song "I hope I just diden't give away the ending" Gregg's voice became extreamly irritating and whiny. I just wanted to say that to all new radicals fans: YOU'RE TASTE IN MUSIC SUCKS, AND YOU SHOULD LISTEN TO OTHER TYPES OF MUSIC OR ARTIST THAT YOU LIKE, JUST NOT THIS CREEP! Save your money and DO NOT buy this album!!!!!!!! 1 out of 5 piece of crap from wannabe-rockers, August 9, 1999 Reviewer: A music fan Please...what that stupid MTV video from those guys? That's the so called "mall-generation", trying to look mean and have an attitude. Bunch of worthless chearleaders. How can you even start considering this junk rock and roll? It's like that SugarRay dude, that sucks as much as the New Radicals. They are even worse, because they claim to be "alternative". Yeah, right. If you want real indie recordings, real rock, real emotions, REAL MUSIC (not that puked-out-big-release-to-make-money), go to early R.E.M., Pavement, Neutral Milk Hotel, Guided By Voices, Folk Implosion, Yo La Tengo, Built to Spill, Belle and Sebastian, Tori Amos. Your soul will thank you. SCREW THAT LEAD SINGER AND HIS FAKE STREETSMART ATTITUDE!!! 2 out of 5 I FOUND THE ALBUM TO BE KIND OF BLAND AT FIRST., December 24, 1998 Reviewer: A music fan IT STARTED OFF AS AN UP BEAT TEMPO, THEN IT SLOWED DOWN WAY TOO MUCH. AFTER LISTENING TO IT FOR THE FIFTYITH TIME IT STARTED TO GROW ON ME. THIS IS AN ALBUM FOR "MTV" CARSON DAILY GROUPIES. FOR YOU TRUE MUSIC LOVERS THIS IS AN ALBUM YOU WILL REGRET BUYING.... 3 out of 5 Not for Pre-teens!, November 26, 1999 By "kimr641" (Indiana) - See all my reviews Yes, they do have an appealing beat, but they have some lyrics that have offensive language. I bought this CD for my 11 year old son, after previewing the 3 sample songs that were available from a retail store. When I gave it to him, I asked to preview the album in its entirety and found the music great, but there are a couple of songs that have lyrics not appropriate for a pre-teen. Further, the CD comes with complete set of the lyrics for the kids to read. Needless to say, the album is now mine, and not for him. Amazon needs to take this off its recommendation list for Ages 9 - 12! Other reviews claim they sound like Todd Rundgren, World Party, Jeff Lynn, and ELO. I have no clue who these groups are :(, but I don't mind their reviews because they are free to their points of views. Now I must research these other artists. By the way, what artists have New Radicals borrowed from? :) Pablo

Elizabeth- 09-09-2007

Grrr...the first two reviews I read pissed me off. :evil: "Not for kids under 13"??? My son is almost 4 and loves MYBBT. I've never thought the lyrics were that bad...not as bad as half the shit on the radio these days...otherwise I'd never let him listen to it! :roll:

Pablo- 09-10-2007

Well some people don't want the drugs stuff on their albums. Hm, definitely don't listen to radio music, unless it's the Spanish radio because the pop music is so dull :(

kastner- 09-11-2007

Grrr...the first two reviews I read pissed me off. :evil: "Not for kids under 13"??? My son is almost 4 and loves MYBBT. I've never thought the lyrics were that bad...not as bad as half the shit on the radio these days...otherwise I'd never let him listen to it! :roll: youngest fan? :lol:

CousinDave- 09-11-2007

These reviews are very interesting... ;) < Other reviews claim they sound like Todd Rundgren, World Party, Jeff Lynn, and ELO. I have no clue who these groups are :(, but I don't mind their reviews because they are free to their points of views. Now I must research these other artists. Pablo You will have a wonderful time discovering each one of them. Anyone who compares you to any of the above is paying you an outstanding complement. Gregg is VERY much like Todd is his producer-ship. I personally wish Gregg would become the Todd of this generation. He is a great producer who is good with new artists and established once popular artists who have fallen off the beaten path as he was good to get them going again. Todd still is a good performer but his voice is going to crap. The only 2 problems with Todd is that his acts always sounded very much like him after awhile and they also would fight with him. I guess both of these things are true with Gregg too.

Elizabeth- 09-11-2007

youngest fan? :lol: Quite possible. If asked his favorite music, he replies, "New Ragals and Carly." (Can't quite say New Radicals yet though...LOL) :lol: And he's always sporting a bucket hat. Maybe someday you'll see little Anthony posting on this site. :lol:

Marisa- 09-13-2007

youngest fan? :lol: Quite possible. If asked his favorite music, he replies, "New Ragals and Carly." (Can't quite say New Radicals yet though...LOL) :lol: And he's always sporting a bucket hat. Maybe someday you'll see little Anthony posting on this site. :lol: eee, that's co cute :wub: i love kids! i love to play with my neighbor, he's like 2 years old and calls me mana lol

CousinDave- 09-13-2007

youngest fan? :lol: Quite possible. If asked his favorite music, he replies, "New Ragals and Carly." (Can't quite say New Radicals yet though...LOL) :lol: And he's always sporting a bucket hat. Maybe someday you'll see little Anthony posting on this site. :lol: eee, that's co cute :wub: i love kids! You ARE a kid! :)

Forumer™ is Voted #1 Free Forum Hosting provider
Build your own community today with the largest message board hosting company.